Rated 4.6 out of 5 by 25
Rated 3 out of 5 by nkfran Leaves eyes greasy
This product does the job however it leaves my eyes feeling greasy. Perhaps I was using too much of the product at once, but for me it's too thick and creamy and leaves lots of residue on my face.
Rated 5 out of 5 by nford Bye Bye to ALL Excess Eye Makeup
Very lightweight. non-greasy lotion that removes all your eye makeup without irritating your delicate eye area. Want to note this is safe for those who wear contact lens wearers as well.
Also can be used as a face cleanser if need be. Very soft and soothing on the skin.
Rated 5 out of 5 by joneskel Wonderful eye makeup remover
This is my first review, but this product is too good not to share. For several years, I have searched for an eye makeup remover that A) works well and B) does not irritate my sensitive eyes. Most makeup removers - and I've tried dozens - make my eyes sting and burn and water so badly that most days I don't even wear eye makeup. Kiehl's Supremely Gentle Eye Make-up Remover
is AMAZING. It works well, and removes all my mascara. It little goes a long way, so it's a good value. More importantly, it soothes my eyes and feels amazing. I've even opened my eyes while using this product and it does not sting or burn at all. I love, love, love this eye makeup remover and will re-order it by the case.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Lbolt I love this stuff
I've been using this eye makeup remover for years. It's gentle, non-greasy and gets through any make-up I use. For a long time I suffered from eye infections but since I switched to Kiehl's everything's changed. I would be lost without it.
Rated 5 out of 5 by LoyalCustomer FAVORITE Product... of ALL Brands!
I have seriously sensitive skin under my eyes. Other products, including expensive, high quality products, burn my skin at first try or after a few consecutive days of a product's use. However, the Supremely Gentle Eye Make-up Remover DOES NOT burn my skin! I Highly Recommend this product to anyone who has this same issue! The remover is so gentle, there is no irritation, and it definitely removes the make-up in one swipe! You do not need to use much of this product either, a little bit goes a long way so the bottle will last a long time!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Petfixr My go-to beauty product
This is the one product I will never be without. I have tried MANY eye makeup removers through the years, but this is the best hands down. Very effective and gentle. I use several coats of mascara and a lash prep and this removes it all. The key is to use enough (about the size of a small bean for each eye works for me) and gently coat all of the lashes then gently wipe off with a tissue. And with the way I use it, the bottle lasts almost a year! Couldn't be a better product or value.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Sami I love this stuff
I love Kiehls products and this is my all time favorite. I will never use anthing else to remove eye makeup.
Rated 2 out of 5 by LP17 moisturizing, but ineffective
There is no double this product is gentle and moisturizing, but it also does not remove my eye make-up well. Maybe it should be sold as an eye cream. I am completely disappointed with it and view it as a waste of money. Wish I'd been able to try a sample first. I use smashbox eyeliner and benefit mascara. It does not effectively remove either. Despite best efforts (holding cotton swab over eye, waiting, gently stroking, following up with water on a cotton swab), the next morning I still find the eye makeup burrowed in the lines under and around my eye.